Nearly all teenagers in a new University of California, San Diego study, 95.5% of 44 aged 15 to 18, predicted that runners chasing winners-only trophies would be more likely to cheat. Among 43 children aged 7 to 9, the figure was 65.1%, a result the researchers could not distinguish from chance.
The gap was wider for safety. All 44 teens said runners in a winners-only race would be more likely to risk getting hurt to win, against 58.1% of the younger children.
How the UC San Diego study worked
Psychologists Shuai Shao and Gail Heyman described two school running events in a study in Developmental Science. Each had ten runners doing one lap around a soccer field. In “Trophies for All,” everyone who showed up got a trophy. In “Trophies for Winners,” only the top three did.
Participants then answered eight either-or questions about which event’s runners would run faster, try less hard, feel more special, feel less proud, cheat, follow the rules, risk injury or run carefully. Children answered in local parks with trained experimenters; teens took the same questions online. The data were gathered in 2024 and 2025 in the southwestern United States.
On effort and pride, both age groups agreed. Winners-only runners would run faster, said 72.1% of children and 100% of teens. Winners-only trophies would feel more special, said 81.4% of children and 95.5% of teens.
The authors summed up the split this way: “children as young as 7 linked reward systems to effort and pride, whereas adolescents additionally made inferences about self‐interest and norm‐conflicting behavior.”
Who wanted which race
Asked which event they would join, 62.8% of children and 63.6% of teens picked the winners-only race, which the researchers did not count as a clear preference. But among teens, those who rated themselves faster than average were more likely to choose it. That link did not appear in the younger group, which the authors read as self-interest starting to shape views on fairness by adolescence.
Why it matters: an old argument, new data
The participation trophy debate is older than most parents involved in it. One of the first known mentions appeared in a 1922 Ohio newspaper item about a high school basketball tournament, and a 2014 national poll found 57% of Americans thought only winners should get trophies while 40% backed trophies for all. The new study adds what young people themselves expect to happen, and when in childhood the darker predictions appear: somewhere between age 9 and age 15.
Badiyaa has covered other studies of how young minds develop, such as research showing babies are not born afraid of snakes. More is on the Science page.
Limits
All participants lived in the United States, and the authors say other cultures may reason differently. They also flag their own wording: asking whether runners would cheat or risk injury “to win” may have steered answers toward the race framed around winning. The questions came in a fixed order, which can make later answers easier to guess.
The study measured what young people predict, not how they behave when trophies are on the line. Its data, analysis code and preregistration are posted publicly on the Open Science Framework.
Further reading
- Shao and Heyman (2026), Trophies for All? (Developmental Science, via PMC)
- Wikipedia: Participation trophy
Image: Ank Kumar, CC BY-SA 4.0 via Wikimedia Commons
This article was produced with AI assistance and reviewed by our Editorial Desk. How we work.



