Black holes weighing less than 1,000 metric tons may have briefly ruled the newborn universe, then evaporated and handed their energy back as heat. A calculation from physicists in Mainz, Germany, and Paris now says that idea is harder to rule out than earlier work suggested, because the gravitational-wave signal it should have left behind is weaker by orders of magnitude.
The study by Yann Gouttenoire, Nicholas Leister and Pedro Schwaller was published on October 29 in Physical Review Letters as "Reduced Gravitational Wave Signal Reopens the Ultralight Primordial Black Hole Window". The full argument is also in the team's free preprint on arXiv.
What counts as a tiny black hole
Primordial black holes are still hypothetical. They would have formed within the first second after the Big Bang, when unusually dense pockets of hot matter collapsed on their own, with no dying star needed. Stephen Hawking argued for them in 1971 and later predicted that small black holes radiate and shrink, as Wikipedia's overview of primordial black holes recounts. None has ever been found.
The Mainz paper deals with the lightest class: anything under a billion grams. The arithmetic is simple. A billion grams is a million kilograms, which is 1,000 metric tons, or about 1,100 US tons. Despite that heft, each one would be far smaller than an atom, and it would evaporate before the universe was old enough to forge its first atomic nuclei during Big Bang nucleosynthesis, a window of roughly 20 minutes.
Why the old prediction was too loud
Most earlier studies assumed every black hole in the population had exactly the same mass. In that picture they all vanish at almost the same moment, and the cosmos snaps from being dominated by black holes back to being dominated by radiation. That sudden switch sets ripples in the density of space ringing, which throws off strong gravitational waves. Physicists nicknamed it the Poltergeist mechanism.
The authors say identical masses are impossible. General relativity's rule for collapse near the threshold, called critical collapse, forces every such population to carry a tail of lighter black holes. Those go first, so the energy leaks out gradually instead of in one burst. In the paper's words, that spread "smooths reheating, suppresses the signal by orders of magnitude, and reopens the ultra-light PBH window." They also call their choice conservative, since they used the narrowest mass spread physics allows.
What it means for detectors
The team compared its prediction with planned observatories including LISA, the Einstein Telescope and Cosmic Explorer, even assuming every astrophysical foreground could be removed. Its conclusion is blunt: "future GW experiments are unlikely to probe ultra-light PBH reheating through GWs," where GW stands for gravitational wave. The upside is that a limit tied to early element formation relaxes too, reopening masses and abundances that had been crossed off.
Same group, opposite end of the scale
Days earlier, Leister and Gouttenoire were also on a study of "stupendously large" black holes above 100 billion Suns, which found that such giants would leave fluctuations in the cosmic microwave background larger than the Planck satellite allows. That paper ran on October 26 in the same journal issue and rules them out as a significant share of dark matter.
The two papers bracket an enormous range. Our star holds about 2 x 10^33 grams, so 100 billion Suns comes to about 2 x 10^44 grams. Divide that by the billion-gram ceiling for the tiny ones and the gap is about 35 powers of ten.
Limits
This is mathematics, not a detection. Hawking radiation has never been observed from a real black hole, and the calculation stops where density ripples turn nonlinear or black holes start merging. For more on how gravity is tested, see Badiyaa's look at Einstein's field equations from November 1915 and the Queensland experiment that sent a message using gravity, or browse our Science section.
The authors list a companion paper on the high-frequency gravitational waves from evaporating black holes as in preparation.
Sources
- Reduced Gravitational Wave Signal Reopens the Ultralight Primordial Black Hole Window, Physical Review Letters (Gouttenoire, Leister, Schwaller), 2026
- Preprint arXiv:2605.21477 (ultralight black hole reheating), arXiv, Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz, 2026
- Closing the Mass Window for Stupendously Large Black Holes (preprint), arXiv, Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz, 2026
- Closing the Mass Window for Stupendously Large Black Holes, Physical Review Letters, 2026
- Primordial black hole, Wikipedia, 2026
- Big Bang nucleosynthesis, Wikipedia, 2026
Image: NASA's Scientific Visualization Studio, Public domain via Wikimedia Commons
This article was produced with AI assistance and reviewed by our Editorial Desk. How we work.




