Royce da 5’9″ and Boogie spent “Dumb” venting about the music business, and they did it over a sample of the Notorious B.I.G. The piano-led single, the third from Royce’s 2018 album Book of Ryan, has resurfaced as one of the most discussed tracks on hip-hop forums this week.
The song landed in April 2018, a couple of weeks before the album. It pairs the Detroit veteran with Boogie, the rapper then signed to Eminem’s Shady Records, trading verses back and forth on what the album’s own credits describe as their frustration with the industry. The beat, credited to S1 and Epikh Pro, borrows from Biggie’s “Just Playing (Dreams).”
The team behind the beat
S1 and Epikh Pro were not one-off hires. The same pair also produced “Caterpillar,” the album single with Eminem and King Green, its Logic remix, and “Amazing” with Melanie Rutherford. S1 also served as a co-executive producer of the whole record, with Mr. Porter and Royce himself as executive producers. “Dumb” runs 3 minutes 7 seconds and sits sixth on the 20-track standard edition, which runs just under 55 minutes.
An album five years in the making
Book of Ryan was recorded between 2013 and 2018 across studios in Michigan, Miami and Las Vegas. Royce had called it his most personal project back in 2016, before his album Layers, then it went quiet for two years before the tracklist and cover finally arrived on March 22, 2018, after his second PRhyme album with DJ Premier.
It came out on May 4, 2018, through Royce’s own Heaven Studios and eOne, with guests including Eminem, J. Cole, Pusha T, Jadakiss, Fabolous, T-Pain, Logic and pianist Robert Glasper. Its Metacritic score of 84 reflects strong reviews.
What the first-week number hides
The album opened at No. 24 on the US albums chart with 19,000 album-equivalent units, 11,000 of them pure sales. Subtract one from the other and about 8,000 units, roughly 42% of the total, came from streams and individual track purchases. Put the other way, 58% of that opening week came from people buying the whole album.
The album also charted in Canada at No. 27 and reached No. 3 on the US chart for indie-label albums.
Seven singles, one long rollout
- “Boblo Boat” with J. Cole, March 2018
- “Stay Woke” with Ashley Sorrell, April 13, 2018
- “Dumb” with Boogie, April 2018
- “Caterpillar” with Eminem and King Green, May 3, 2018
- “Amazing” and “Power,” August and September 2018
- “Cocaine,” January 18, 2019
The Shady connection runs through plenty of recent Detroit stories on Badiyaa, from IDK’s Welcome with Eminem over a J Dilla beat to the 30th anniversary of Eminem’s debut album Infinite. The city’s current underground is covered in our piece on Boldy James’s 12-track Bentayga Genesis.
Royce followed Book of Ryan with The Allegory in 2020.
Further reading
Image: Andrew Heneen, CC BY 4.0 via Wikimedia Commons
This article was produced with AI assistance and reviewed by our Editorial Desk. How we work.



