Monday, 16 November 2026

Trusted News Discovery – Powered by AI and Verified by Humans

Gene Kelly’s dances in The Pirate go viral again; MGM’s boss had a third number with Judy Garland burned

Gene Kelly's Nina and Be a Clown dances from The Pirate (1948) are trending, but MGM burned the negatives of his Voodoo number with Judy Garland.

Produced with AI assistance and reviewed by the Badiyaa Editorial Desk. How we work.

Verified by humans. Checked by machines. Open to you.

Grok Fact CheckCheck it yourself in one tapVerify with Grok ↗Ask @grok on X ↗
A Howard Pyle illustration of a pirate at rest, the kind of storybook buccaneer Gene Kelly's character pretends to be in The Pirate.
Image: Howard Pyle, Public domain via Wikimedia Commons

Louis B. Mayer was so shocked by one Gene Kelly and Judy Garland dance in The Pirate that he ordered the negatives burned. Not a frame of that number, “Voodoo,” is known to survive. What did survive, Kelly’s acrobatic “Nina” and the slapstick “Be a Clown,” is drawing new fans all over again.

Clips of Kelly’s routines from the 1948 MGM musical are circulating on Reddit this week, introducing one of his least-known films to a new audience.

A dancer playing a swashbuckler

Vincente Minnelli directed the film from a script by Albert Hackett and Frances Goodrich, based on S. N. Behrman’s 1942 play. Cole Porter wrote the songs. Garland plays Manuela, a young woman in a Caribbean village who dreams of a legendary pirate named Macoco. Kelly is Serafin, a traveling performer who pretends to be that pirate to win her over.

Kelly built the role on his childhood film heroes, the athletic Douglas Fairbanks and the theatrical John Barrymore. He wanted a different style of dance from his earlier work. In his words, he was after “a popular style with a lot of classic forms, acrobatics, and athletics.”

The Nina number

For “Nina,” MGM built an entire town plaza on a soundstage, complete with a pavilion and deliberately uneven cobblestones. The set alone cost $86,660. Kelly uses all of it, flirting his way across the square in one of his most athletic solo routines.

Be a Clown and the Nicholas Brothers

The first version of “Be a Clown” pairs Kelly with the Nicholas Brothers, the famous dancing duo. Theater owners in the segregated South cut the number from their prints, fearing white audiences would object to two Black dancers sharing the screen with a white star as equals. Garland and Kelly reprise the song at the finale.

The tune had an odd afterlife. Screenwriter Betty Comden later said Arthur Freed’s “Make ’em Laugh” from Singin’ in the Rain sounded just like it: “It’s fabulous, but the song’s exactly like ‘Be a Clown.”

A troubled shoot and a money-loser

Filming began February 17, 1947. Garland was struggling with exhaustion and prescription drugs, and she missed 99 of 135 days of rehearsals and shooting. The film came in at $3,768,496, more than half a million dollars over budget.

According to MGM’s own accounts, North American theaters returned $1,874,000 and the rest of the world another $782,000, leaving the studio $2,290,000 in the red. In other words, the studio got back only about 70 cents for every dollar it spent making the film, before marketing. The score still earned an Oscar nomination.

Share this story

Freed later argued the film was simply early: “I think today The Pirate would be a hit. It was twenty years ahead of its time.” Kelly blamed himself, calling his take “a huge inside joke” that didn’t land.

Warner Archive released a restored 4K transfer on Blu-ray in November 2020, which is where many of the sharp clips now going around come from.

For more classic Hollywood, read how Audrey Hepburn and Cary Grant made Charade and the story of Dorothy Dandridge, the first Black woman nominated for the best actress Oscar.

Further reading

Image: Howard Pyle, Public domain via Wikimedia Commons

This article was produced with AI assistance and reviewed by our Editorial Desk. How we work.

Spot an error? Help verify this story

Join our Reader Verifiers. Every report is read by an editor.

Grok Fact CheckCheck it yourself in one tapVerify with Grok ↗Ask @grok on X ↗

Verified by humans. Checked by machines. Open to you.