---
title: "‘Sing a Song of Sixpence’ put four and twenty naughty boys, not blackbirds, in its first printed pie in 1744"
url: https://badiyaa.com/sing-song-sixpence-nursery-rhyme-origins/
published: 2026-11-18T14:12:00+00:00
modified: 2026-11-18T14:12:00+00:00
section: History
publisher: Badiyaa
---

# ‘Sing a Song of Sixpence’ put four and twenty naughty boys, not blackbirds, in its first printed pie in 1744

'Sing a Song of Sixpence' was first printed in London around 1744 with naughty boys in the pie; blackbirds replaced them in a version from about 1780.

The oldest printed version of “Sing a Song of Sixpence” has no blackbirds in it. In a London collection called Tommy Thumb’s Pretty Song Book, printed in about 1744, the pie holds something else entirely: “Four and twenty Naughty Boys, Baked in a Pye.” The birds only flew in later.

That swap is one of several surprises in the history of the English nursery rhyme, which is listed as number 13191 in the Roud Folk Song Index, the standard catalog of traditional songs.

## How the rhyme grew, verse by verse

- **c. 1602 and 1614:** Possible echoes appear on stage. In Shakespeare’s Twelfth Night, Sir Toby Belch offers a clown “sixpence for you: let’s have a song,” and Beaumont and Fletcher’s Bonduca includes the cry “Sing a song o’ sixpence!”

- **c. 1744:** The first verse is printed, with naughty boys and a “bag full of Rye.”

- **c. 1780:** The next surviving version runs to two verses, and the boys have become birds.

- **1784:** Gammer Gurton’s Garland prints something close to the modern four verses, ending with a magpie attacking the unlucky maid.

- **Mid-1800s:** Gentler fifth verses appear, in which the king’s doctor sews her nose back on or a little Jenny wren returns it.

The rhyme was long credited to the scholar George Steevens, who used it in 1790 to pun on the name of Poet Laureate Henry James Pye. The 1744 printing shows it was already in circulation decades earlier.

## Could you really bake live birds into a pie?

Yes, at least as a party trick. Sixteenth-century cooks served pies with live birds inside, a theatrical course known as an entremet. A 1549 Italian cookbook, which reached English readers in 1598, explained how “to make pies so that birds may be alive in them and fly out when it is cut up.” John Nott’s cookbook referred to the idea again in 1725. When Marie de’ Medici married Henry IV of France in 1600, guests reportedly unfolded their napkins to find songbirds flying out.

So the dish set before the king was a real banquet stunt, not pure fantasy. The birds were baked into the crust’s hollow, not cooked themselves.

## The theories, and the hoax

Iona and Peter Opie’s 1951 Oxford Dictionary of Nursery Rhymes collected the symbolic readings: the king and queen as symbols of the day and night skies, the 24 blackbirds as the hours of the day; or the birds as monks during Henry VIII’s dissolution of the monasteries, with Catherine of Aragon as the queen and Anne Boleyn as the maid. No evidence backs any of these, and since the first version featured boys rather than birds, most could not be original.

One explanation is known to be false. The popular story that Blackbeard the pirate used the rhyme as a coded recruiting call was invented in 1999 by a myth-busting website as a deliberate fake, one of a series of planted legends meant to test readers’ skepticism. A 2003 TV show about urban legends later presented it as true before correcting the answer in later airings.

The coin in the title has a firm history at least. England first minted the sixpence in 1551, and it went out of use in 1980 after Britain moved to decimal money in 1971. For more of the stories behind familiar songs, browse [Badiyaa’s History section](https://badiyaa.com/category/history/), or see how modern kids’ music still borrows from old rhymes in [Gracie’s Corner’s Tiny Desk concert with Paul Wall](https://badiyaa.com/gracies-corner-tiny-desk-paul-wall/).

## Further reading

- [Wikipedia: Sing a Song of Sixpence](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sing_a_Song_of_Sixpence)

*Image: Andreas Trepte, CC BY-SA 2.5 via Wikimedia Commons*

*This article was produced with AI assistance and reviewed by our Editorial Desk. [How we work](https://badiyaa.com/editorial-policy/).*
