---
title: "School phone bans pay off slowly; a Florida district’s test scores rose only in the second year"
url: https://badiyaa.com/school-phone-bans-test-scores-second-year/
published: 2026-11-18T08:12:00+00:00
modified: 2026-11-18T08:12:00+00:00
section: Science
publisher: Badiyaa
---

# School phone bans pay off slowly; a Florida district’s test scores rose only in the second year

School phone bans raised test scores only in their second year in a large Florida district, while a national pouch study found near-zero average effects.

School phone bans do not raise test scores overnight, and two of the largest studies so far suggest the payoff, where it comes at all, arrives in year two. In a big urban Florida district, scores showed no meaningful change in the first year of an all-day ban, then climbed in the second, with spring results up 1.1 percentile points on average.

A national study of lockable phone pouches, revised in September, found the same rough first year followed by recovery. Its verdict on grades is more cautious: across all schools, average effects on test scores stayed close to zero, though high schools saw modest gains, especially in math.

## The Florida district: a slow climb

Economists David N. Figlio and Umut Özek tracked one of the 10 largest school districts in the United States, which went further than the state law. Students had to keep phones silenced and stored in backpacks all day, including lunch and the walks between classes. Their [working paper on the Florida ban](https://doi.org/10.3386/w34388) follows students from the 2022-23 school year, before the ban, through 2024-25.

Smartphone location data showed daytime phone activity in schools falling by roughly two-thirds. The early months were bumpy. Suspensions in September 2023 ran 25% above the same month a year before, and in-school suspensions for Black male students rose 30% at the schools most affected. By the start of the next school year, discipline had dropped back to near pre-ban levels.

Test scores followed the opposite curve. Nothing significant moved in year one. In year two, gains appeared, concentrated in spring testing, among boys (up 1.4 percentiles) and in middle and high schools (up 1.3). Unexcused absences also fell, and the researchers estimate better attendance could explain up to half of the score improvement.

## The national pouch study: well-being first

The second study, from a six-person team that includes Hunt Allcott, E. Jason Baron, Thomas Dee and Matthew Gentzkow, looked at schools across the country that adopted lockable pouches. They combined a large teacher survey, GPS pings, standardized test results, school records and sales data from the biggest pouch supplier. The study was pre-registered, meaning the analysis plan was published in advance.

According to the [national pouch paper](https://doi.org/10.3386/w35132), phone use dropped sharply. In the first year, disciplinary incidents rose and there were signs that student well-being dipped. In later years the discipline effect faded and well-being recovered, then turned positive. On scores, high schools gained modestly while middle schools slipped slightly, netting out near zero. The team found little change in attendance and no clear improvement in students’ reported attention or online bullying.

## What the two studies say together

Read side by side, the studies share a shape: a disruptive first year, then improvement as students and staff adjust. They differ on how much reaches the report card. A 1.1 percentile gain means a student at the 50th percentile moving to roughly the 51st, real but small. That makes the second year, not the first semester, the fair point at which to judge any ban.

## Limits

The Florida result comes from a single district that the researchers did not name, and both papers are working papers rather than final journal articles. Neither study randomly assigned schools to bans, so both rely on comparing schools that changed policy with those that had not yet done so.

For other recent research on how children learn, see our report on a [study comparing young musicians’ memory and math scores](https://badiyaa.com/music-training-children-memory-northeastern/), and more findings in our [Science section](https://badiyaa.com/category/science/). The authors of the Florida study plan a future version tracking classroom climate and student well-being.

## Further reading

- [NBER Working Paper 35132: The Effects of School Phone Bans](https://doi.org/10.3386/w35132)

- [NBER Working Paper 34388: Cell Phone Bans in Schools, Evidence from Florida](https://doi.org/10.3386/w34388)

*Image: Tomwsulcer, CC0 via Wikimedia Commons*

*This article was produced with AI assistance and reviewed by our Editorial Desk. [How we work](https://badiyaa.com/editorial-policy/).*
