---
title: "The feeling of being stared at has failed lab tests since 1898; a 1913 study scored 50.2%, near pure chance"
url: https://badiyaa.com/psychic-staring-effect-feeling-watched-tests/
published: 2026-11-18T07:18:00+00:00
modified: 2026-11-18T07:18:00+00:00
section: Science
publisher: Badiyaa
---

# The feeling of being stared at has failed lab tests since 1898; a 1913 study scored 50.2%, near pure chance

The psychic staring effect, the feeling of being watched, has failed controlled tests since Edward Titchener's 1898 trials; a 1913 study scored 50.2%.

Most people have felt it: a prickle on the back of the neck, a turn of the head, and there is someone looking right at you. Psychologists have been trying to catch that sixth sense in the lab since 1898, and it keeps slipping away. In one of the earliest controlled tests, people asked whether they were being watched were right 50.2% of the time, almost exactly what a coin toss would give.

The idea has a formal name, the [psychic staring effect](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychic_staring_effect), sometimes called scopaesthesia. It is the claim that a person can detect a stare without seeing or hearing the starer.

## Where the idea came from

Psychologist Edward B. Titchener first studied it after junior students told him they could feel eyes on them in classrooms and public halls. A few even believed that staring at the back of someone’s neck could make that person turn around. His students described the feeling as “a state of unpleasant tingling, which gathers in volume and intensity until a movement which shall relieve it becomes inevitable.”

Titchener ran laboratory trials on both claims. The results, he reported, were invariably negative. He also offered a down-to-earth explanation. When you turn your head, anyone already facing your way notices the movement and looks at you. You then meet their eyes and assume they had been staring all along. The tingle itself, he argued, comes from focusing attention on your own neck, much as thinking about your knee makes it feel more sensitive.

## A century of tests

The record since then runs in one direction:

- 1913: John E. Coover tested ten subjects over 100 possible staring periods. They scored 50.2%, which he called an “astonishing approximation” of chance. He judged the feeling common but groundless.

- 1983: a study using closed-circuit cameras reported a 74% success rate, but later researchers found the order of staring and non-staring trials had not been properly randomized.

- 2000s: parapsychologist Rupert Sheldrake reported a hit rate of 53.1%. Critics noted his sequences had too few long runs and too many alternations, a pattern people can learn without realizing it.

- 2004: a test measuring skin conductance came back negative. Its authors concluded that “the staring paradigm is not the easily replicable paradigm that it is claimed to be.”

- 2009: another camera and skin-conductance study, with starers kept busy on computer games between trials, failed to show a clear effect.

## What the numbers mean

Coover’s ten subjects made 1,000 guesses between them. Pure chance predicts 500 right answers; 50.2% means 502, a surplus of two. Sheldrake’s 53.1% is bigger, about 31 extra hits per 1,000 guesses, but it is exactly the kind of small edge that disappears when sequences are truly random. Psychologist Michael Shermer also raised concerns in 2005 about confirmation bias and experimenter bias in such tests.

## Why the feeling is real anyway

None of this means the sensation is imaginary. Humans are very good at spotting where other people are looking. Our eyes have an unusually visible white sclera around a well-defined iris, which makes gaze direction easy to read and is thought to have helped our ancestors communicate and spot threats. That detection runs below conscious awareness and draws on peripheral vision, so a glance caught at the edge of sight can feel like a hunch out of nowhere.

The brain’s habit of quietly rewiring sense signals is a theme in our story on [barn owls that retuned their hearing to match shifted sight](https://badiyaa.com/barn-owls-prism-goggles-knudsen-hearing/). For another scientist who took psychic claims seriously a century ago, see how [Nobel winner Charles Richet coined the word ectoplasm](https://badiyaa.com/charles-richet-ectoplasm-nobel-anaphylaxis/).

A study surveying students in 1913 found that over two thirds reported having the feeling. In more than a hundred years, no controlled test has shown they could actually do it.

## Further reading

- [Wikipedia: Psychic staring effect](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychic_staring_effect)

- [Wikipedia: Edward B. Titchener](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edward_B._Titchener)

*Image: Ramon FVelasquez, CC BY-SA 3.0 via Wikimedia Commons*

*This article was produced with AI assistance and reviewed by our Editorial Desk. [How we work](https://badiyaa.com/editorial-policy/).*
